Learning Composition: The Rule of Thirds


  • Shares
  • 4
    Comments

Rule of thirds Whether you’re feeling artistic or not, good composition is important for making images that resonate with viewers. Everything else being equal, poor composition can create an itch in a viewer—a subconscious and annoying one that can’t be scratched.

Composition in photography refers to the arrangement of elements in an image. Those elements can be subjects, foreground, background, and props. They can also be color, focus, and balance.

It can be a difficult concept to grasp which is why people invented “the rule of thirds.” Here’s what Wikipedia says about the Rule:

The rule of thirds is a compositional rule of thumb in photography and other visual arts such as painting and design. The rule states that an image can be divided into nine equal parts by two equally-spaced horizontal lines and two equally-spaced vertical lines. The four points formed by the intersections of these lines can be used to align features in the photograph. Proponents of this technique claim that aligning a photograph with these points creates more tension, energy and interest in the photo than simply centering the feature would. — The Rule of Thirds, Wikipedia

The theory is that aligning your subject along one of the lines or at an intersection makes a stronger composition. Let’s see how that works out in the example below:

Original uncropped

I shot this image yesterday. The model is my daughter. This is the uncropped (though obviously resized) image. I’ve drawn the rule of thirds lines on the image. As you can see, the subject is centered. The photo isn’t bad but I think it can be improved with a little cropping.

Crop 1

Crop 2

The two crops above take two different approaches. In the first, I’ve aligned the model’s eyes with the first horizontal line. The idea, since this is a portrait of a person, is to make eye contact with the viewer. Humans are genetically wired to respond strongly to eyes and faces.

The second is a much more severe crop which attempts to align not only the top horizontal line but also both vertical lines. In my opinion, it definitely draws you into her eyes more.

However, I think both of those crops (and the original) suffer from a lack of balance. In all three of the above images, the right side of the photo feels “heavier” to me. This is caused by the large patch of black hair on the right. When I look at this photo I feel slightly uncomfortable. Almost as if the image will fall over if it isn’t propped up by something. In addition, the bottom crop feels unbalanced vertically with her chin being cut off.

Final crop

This final crop addresses the balance problem. The hair is still there but I’ve shifted everything to the left and thankfully she has a complete chin again. The left eye is almost at the top left intersection. I cropped the image so that it was below the intersection to balance the image vertically. I think this is a much stronger crop than all of the others, including the original, and is the version I published.

As you can see, the rule of thirds is a really just a guideline. And it isn’t something you’re supposed to follow blindly. Rather, it’s a distillation of wisdom regarding the placement of objects within your camera frame to achieve the strongest composition. I keep it in the back of my mind and use it as a helpful reference. But I often crop images without consciously using it (or even better—compose in the camera with this in mind) and find that important elements of the image happen to fall on the rule of thirds lines and intersections anyway.

John is the original founder of Photodoto, but after running it for 4 years he had to focus on different things. If you're interested in what John has been up to recently, you can check is personal blog or browse his photo blog.
Google+